Bloop by xCryptic: https://gist.github.com/notcryptic/5e72f6d32eb3df053ea0ad8e234d892f
Give him/her your thanks!
REQUEST ANIME! I WILL FULLFILL THE REQUESTS IF IT IS POSSIBLE (AND MOST OF THE TIME IT IS!)
FAQ:
Reason this torrent is so big compared to others is that this is a BDMV, basically a identical copy of the actual blu-ray, if you were to buy the blu-ray and open the directory, you would see what you are seeing when you download this. Other torrents may source their videos from blu-rays but encode it so save space.
If you aren’t an enthusiast and just want to watch an anime and get over it, THIS IS NOT FOR YOU. THERE ARE ENCODES FOR YOU! EVEN SOMETIMES WITH BETTER IMAGE LIKE WITH EVANGELION!
Download and install VLC: https://www.videolan.org/vlc/index.html
Go to the top left and click Media.
Click Open Disc. In Disc Selection click Blu-Ray.
Under Disc Device you put the directory of where your torrent is, so for example if you have yours in your default downloads folder in Windows and want to play the first disc, put this in Disc device:
C:\Users\ShinningFinger\Downloads[BDMV][USA] Attack on Titan Season 3\Attack on Titan Season 3 Part 1\AttackOnTitan_S3_P1_D1\
Then click play and it should play! If you have any problems feel free to comment!
So that everyone can watch it in either English dubs or Japanese with english subs. This BDMV offers the option for both. The Japanese blu-ray only has Japanese.
ABSOLUTELY! PLEASE DO! I promise that if you request an anime no matter how obscure it is I will do my very best to find it and share it, hell if you want you can leave a way for me to notify you when I found it and have it and I will do so.
REQUEST ANIME! I WILL FULLFILL THE REQUESTS IF IT IS POSSIBLE (AND MOST OF THE TIME IT IS!)
Notes about this particular release:
All credits go to jdcox215 over at U2 for releasing this, I want to thank the person but also fuck people who only release on private trackers. Everyone should have access to this, not just a handful of people you deem worthy.
IMDb Link…: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2560140/
aniDB Link…: http://anidb.net/a14444
Genre…: Action | Drama | Fantasy | Horror
Distributor…: FUNimation
Year…: 2019
Country…: Japan
Director…: Tetsurou Araki
Source…: BD50 Retail
Blu-ray Codec…: AVC
Blu-ray Size…: 2xBD50
Programs Used…: AnyDVD HD
Screen Format…: Widescreen
Resolution…: 1080p
Subtitles…: English
Menu…: Untouched
Video…: Untouched
Audio…: Untouched
Extras…: Untouched
Audio:
Audio: English / Dolby TrueHD Audio / 5.1 / 48 kHz / 1735 kbps / 16-bit (AC3 Embedded: 5.1 / 48 kHz / 448 kbps / DN -31dB)
Audio: Japanese / Dolby TrueHD Audio / 2.0 / 48 kHz / 1231 kbps / 24-bit (AC3 Embedded: 2.0 / 48 kHz / 192 kbps / DN -27dB)
Subtitle: English / 34.484 kbps
Fuck private trackers. Someone explain to me why this wasn’t released to the public in the first place and I will stop “leaking” them.
Comments - 370
pip3
yes. in the long time we’ll need a large scale, decentralized network of peers sharing everything.
charman01
and there it is season 3¡ , I really want to get the full saga in english… THANK U VERY MUCH…and for my request of Full metal panic and Relife…thanks for you answer… I suppose you can get them so I’ll wait patiently…I guess you will be busy in these days uploading good content like this so…Keep it up and Thanks again.
zMega
Thanks for doing that, it’s greatly appreciated man. And I have a request, could you upload the Inuyasha US BDMV? Here you can find the spanish one, but not those.
KaoriScarlet1997
From what i know, private trackers have torrents which are 10 years or even older which are still being seeded due to the rules and restrictions required to follow. This makes sure that there are incredibly less torrents which are not seeded. In nyaa, a lot of people download and dont seed as the rules dont require you to have a seeding ratio and stuff hence a lot of leechers, very less seeders.
These people invest in seedboxes, supply a lot of BDMV’s and seed a lot so there is a difference, its not just a mind over matter question. Im saying this even though I dont possess a private tracker access.
zechs
what’s your current Upload Queue?
valid
@KaoriScarlet1997
they are decent archives but some are so hard to get to that they should really not be doing any exclusives. the ratio rules also make it so that a huge part of their torrents may have no activity in years because everyone is worried about their ratio. put the same torrent here and people will still be downloading it frequently even 10 years later
KaoriScarlet1997
@ valid, for downloading the same torrent 10 years later, there needs to be a seeder and that is what we dont find here. Maybe someone has statistics for it but i see recent torrents which are not seeded within a month or so. Moreover some uploaders here put up BDMV’s and seed it for a month or two and there are still no seeders apart from them.
valid
@KaoriScarlet1997
i know and that sucks. but the private trackers have an accessibility problem because just being a good user who seeds what they download wont get you in. it can take several years and lots of hard work to get in and you have to hope that nothing happens to the trackers before you get on them and have had time to build up decent stats so you can actually download something
KaoriScarlet1997
@valid That is true tho. Most of them are borderline impossible to get in.
jdcox215
Quit leaking my shit.
Glordit
kek
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@zechs
Can’t say right now sorry, all requests will be done given enough time, this is far from my last leak.
@jdcox215
Why exactly? As stated in the readme:
tomyud
please upload OVERLORD usa bluray thanks!!
ChaoXide
inb4 all bdmv sharers just stop sharing and then people get fucked without any sources. :/
already seen dozens of providers stop because of this and now fansubbers are having difficulty getting bdmv’s for their fansub projects.
NiTr0gLiTcH
cant wait to see u banned from u2
Aronz
screw private trackers this is freeeedom…
private trackers comes down Nyaa goes up…
Jorex342
It could be cool you upload the entire JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure JP BDMV
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@ChaoXide
Again, as stated in the readme:
Explain why this wasn’t made public and if it’s actually a legit reason I will stop leaking. Simple as that.
Glordit
Exclusive torrents is a oxymoron.
skolastico
You want an explanation for why wasn’t this uploaded to the public then let me explain you.
When someone buys something from their own money they are entitled to do whatever they want with it. If they want to uploaded to private trackers its their own buisness.
And since you said “fuck private trackers” well let me remind you that most of the things that appears on the internet comes from private places and then goes public, if people dont want to share to the public you only have to accept it :D
Glordit
Uploading them to the internet to give to other people for free, is considered copywrite infringement. We all here breaking the law anyway. What does it matter if some one else stole it from another thief?
Aronz
you all people support private tracker why come here… don’t you have places to worry about your ratios.
ChaoXide
It doesn’t matter why it was or wasn’t uploaded here or there. The point is: you piss off the hand that feeds you, eventually they stop feeding you.
Far too many people have quit sharing because of people like you and it’s really killed fansubbers ability to obtain BDMVs.
The best course of action is to keep those feeding you happy so they continue to do so. Regardless of how dumb their “exclusive” bs is.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
I refuse to accept it, leaks will continue since you did not satisfy the “legit reason” requirement.
I believe everyone should have access to this, not just a select few you deem worthy. If someone gives me a legit reason for why this was not published publicly and why I should not leak them, then I promise I will stop leaking. But no one has provided a legit reason, the leaks will continue till then.
If this community depends on whinny babies who can’t handle BDMVs leaving their sacred group for no reason then this community should collapse. If the whinny babies stop feeding then we’ll group up and buy BDMVs ourselves, splitting the cost among us. And then share to everyone, like it should be.
Aronz
animebytes invite 130$
u2 invite 60$
look How people are this much Money hungry over an invite … if it continues near future cost a kidney
so once again screw private tracker…
Ken-Sama
???
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@Aronz
animebytes invite 130$
u2 invite 60$
look How people are this much Money hungry over an invite … if it continues near future cost a kidney
so once again screw private tracker…
Care to ask them for me which torrents they want from them? I’ll leak em tomorrow.
ChaoXide
Alright then, I ask you to please help fund BDMVs that fansub groups need but can’t get. MHA S3 was FINALLY just recently crowdfunded after years because the original BDMV sharer stopped sharing.
Fire Force still doesn’t have a BDMV. MHA S4 hasn’t been funded or shared. Kado, Berserk, hundreds of other shows… Still waiting for JP BDMV.
I’d love to see you manage to crowdfund dozens of shows per season when a single show is $300 to $600 each. That would be fabulous. However this has not happened and thus many fansub projects were dropped due to lack of BDMV. Why is there a lack of BDMV? Because the big providers ran off due to people like you who have not managed to fill the hole left by the actions you thought were more important.
Actions have consequence and all I see is starving people.
areen
lmao
@ShinningFinger
Btw, do you have fairy tail jojo bd?
Thanks anyway, appreciate your releases.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@ChaoXide
Where do I go to help fund them? Haven’t looked into it much but from what I could tell they only use it for their encodes and don’t release the actual BDMV.
jeebs10
This right here is the reason the PTs are hard to get into. If people were cool, many more people would be allowed in. But because of people like you, people are very careful with who they invite. So, blame yourself and people with the same mentality for making the PTs so inaccessible.
Aronz
@ShinningFinger i will support you till my death .there are people who cant afford this .
this is a public tracker .
private trakies if you have any complaint go to your private tracker forum this not the place for your unnecessary complaints. jeez you guys are full spoiled by those private demons .only thing i can see from you is jealousy there is no hope for you guys
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@areen
Yes I do, but those are both massive and will come at a later date when I am done with a lot of these small ones. Don’t worry it’s in my drive already, but my bandwidth only allows so much at once, with the 5 I’m uploading now it’s already congested, so it’ll have to wait a bit.
Want me to notify you somehow when I upload them or you’ll keep an eye out?
HiggerNunter
I hope this doesn’t backfire hard, mainly worried about;
KaoriScarlet1997
@ShinningFinger, are you willing to never have new BDMV’s uploaded because of the short term satisfaction of leaking some BD’s? I know you are doing this for a good cause but this will lead to no bdrips or bdmv’s of upcoming shows. For eg Kimetsu no yaiba was not uploaded for 1 year or so because the bdmv’s were leaked. I would be happy if you could give me 1 good reason why the BDMV uploaders should give you or me a reason to upload here. We should be happy that they are uploading for free may it be bdrip or bdmv luckily.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@Kaori
Same reason they have for uploading to private trackers.
SeaSmoke
I’m guessing that you’re referring to what happened with Kimetsu no Yaiba, which had no BDMVs released for a while and only Kaleido was releasing it (fansubs). The BDMV provider got pissed off because people were leaking his PT uploads to public trackers, so he stopped uploading to the PT. He decided to give the BDMVs directly to kaleido and asked them to encode it. This happens because of people like you. At least PTs were getting the BDMVs, and through that most fansubbers and encoders had access to it. Since people started mass leaking stuff, more people have stopped uploading to PTs, which is why so many shows don’t have any BDMVs released for a long time. If you’re so insistent on sharing to the public, why don’t you buy BDs for stuff which isn’t available and upload it here (what Lupin the Nerd did, but he also got pissed off because of leakers and ended up quitting).
KaoriScarlet1997
@ShinningFinger, that is their wish right, may it be logical or not? Are you willing to not have your fav shows in BDMV or bdrip quality ever again?I also tried lots of forums but never got in but atleast people upload some BD’s here and Im happy with that. Let me tell you one thing, its better to not cut the branch we are sitting on.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@SeaSmoke
Why did he not want his BDMVs in public trackers?
I intend to, yes. So far I have some 10TB of private BDMVs to go through first on my drives, afterwards once I start encountering ones that are not on private trackers or anywhere I will buy them and share them to everyone, because why wouldn’t I? Seriously I have asked many times now why people don’t just upload their BDMVs to everyone and have not gotten a valid reason, “because they want to” is not an explanation.
HiggerNunter
prolly cuz of leechers and as stated previously, “private trackers have torrents which are 10 years or even older which are still being seeded”.
[playing devil’s advocate plus I assumed you used the same torrent, from PT uploader, then uploading here]
DonCanjas
Do you even have a brain?
That’s a USBD, so its quality is doubtful.
If it was released only on U2, it’s because the uploader intended to do so. It’s none of your business reuploading other people’s work just because you don’t like PTs.
Is that supposed a joke? Why are you recommending VLC? I don’t know what’s worst, not recognizing that VLC is bad or thinking that a person (with knowledge on the matter) in seek for quality would want that release.
Plus, you’re releasing something in english. There are a ton of other releases in english, like the Scyrou’s one which is amazing. I can assure you that a lot of people would prefer Scyrou’s Attack on Titan release over this torrent. I am portuguese and, unfortunately, I don’t have the same choices when dealing with anime. If there is a official BD release with portuguese subs/dub it’s a spanish BD. I never in my life had the chance to get my hands on one of those and the only way to get them is by downloading from PTs. That makes my seek for higher quality releases harder since I’ll have to do it by myself or hoping that someone in my country takes care of it. You don’t need any effort to get what you want with the quality you want in english
ShinningFinger (uploader)
That’s the public tracker’s problem though? Why not just upload it and leave it to the public tracker’s community to seed it? If it dies, it dies, he at least tried lol
Scoped
You’ve been given numerous reasons to stop leaking shit. Please listen to them. We don’t want a world where even PT uploaders stop uploading because of retards like you trying to gain nyaa points for being the right hand of justice in their retarded eyes. Least you could have done is remux it lmao.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
Again I ask, why do they not want their releases on public trackers?
CptJackSparrow
Do you have One Punch Man S2 vol 2?
HiggerNunter
Welp idk bro. I’m dumbstruck.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
The US BD isn’t out for season 2 yet, I’ll release it all once it does, I think it was delayed due to covid,
NiTr0gLiTcH
wew, u guys know a shitload of people got in for free just by asking politely here on nyaa under the comments?
invites costs coins and the inviters risk by inviting people they dont know, since they could behave as The Idiot up here, but they do it anyways.
so, if u didnt manage to get in it’s only ur fault
Archer0034
Why would the uploader stop sharing on U2 if their stuff gets leaked? I mean there’s no harm to U2 users, it’s just that more people will have access to the content if it gets uploaded to nyaa. Serious question.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
I have been asking this question for years and have yet to be given an actual answer, even after saying I will stop leaking if I am given a valid answer.
KaoriScarlet1997
@Archer0034 Would you share your stuff in a community where other people also share and seed your stuff for a long time or upload it in a place where countless people download and almost no one else seeds after a while? People upload so that someday they can download it back even if they delete their personal copy and thats why private trackers exist with strict rules. Lets say you buy a BD worth 600 gb and upload it today and seed it for a month to make sure some people download it. Then lets say by mistake your hdd crashes or you lose track of your seedbox details in a course of 10 years and come back to find your torrent is dead with no seeders. Thats where the real difference between trackers come as you would still see your torrent live in a Private tracker after all these years and reseed requests are accepted. People upload in private trackers because they know that the fellow community people will always support that torrent and also upload their own copies of BDMV’s to do so.
Scoped
Because you should honour the providers that you rely on, don’t disincentivise them from uploading. They each have their own reasons for not wanting their uploads on Nyaa and you should honour that.
moonship
@ShinningFinger
Hey man great work
small request if possible please upload Bleach BDMV’s
KaoriScarlet1997
@ShinningFinger Maybe you dont know but there are many U2 members who get banned because they shared some U2 exclusive torrent to a person and that person uploaded it to nyaa. Check out the violet evergarden movie BDMV release here and some person was banned from U2. Its no joke.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@KaoriScarlet1997
Don’t have the ability to just upload to private trackers AND public ones? How hard can that be?
@moonship
Will do so after the 8th volume comes out in late September.
Archer0034
@KaoriScarlet1997 Yeah that’s perfectly fine and reasonable. But is there any problem if someone else gets it from U2 and upload it to nyaa? The original uploader would still be able to access their stuff if they ever wanted to since it is on U2.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
Maybe if they told me their reasons I would honor it.
I am tired of replying to pointless comments. Only responding to actual arguments or requests from now on, just wasting my time
jyal
@ShinningFinger here new bdmv that not found on any tracker :-
https://www.amazon.com/Fuuka-Complete-Blu-ray-Keizou-Kusakawa/dp/B07QPCGV17
https://www.amazon.com/How-Not-Summon-Demon-Lord/dp/B07QXZYHBC
https://www.amazon.com/Love-Tyrant-Complete-Atsushi-Nigorikawa/dp/B07PZN49QJ
https://www.amazon.com/Kakuriyo-Breakfast-Spirits-Part-Blu-ray/dp/B07NRFGFCY
https://www.amazon.com//dp/B07T4MV6V8
https://www.amazon.com/Dances-Dragons-Complete-Blu-ray/dp/B07MTJLXDQ
https://www.amazon.com/Angels-Death-Complete-Dallas-Reid/dp/B07TMRRPJ2
https://www.amazon.com/ISLAND-Complete-Blu-ray-Island/dp/B07QN8PV93
https://www.amazon.com/Lord-Vermillion-Complete-Uncut-Blu-ray/dp/B07T4RYNPD
https://www.amazon.com/Ulysses-Jeanne-Alchemist-Complete-Blu-ray/dp/B07TNVX3QY
https://www.amazon.com/My-Roommate-Cat-Complete-Blu-ray/dp/B07WNKT3BM
https://www.amazon.com/Cop-Craft-Complete-Blu-ray-Digital/dp/B087677WJ5
https://www.amazon.com/Astra-Lost-Space-Complete-Blu-ray/dp/B0892B9MS6
i intended to buy them but i it will take 45-60 day and there no free shipping so i gave up for now, waiting for free shipping to return…
CptJackSparrow
@ShinningFinger can you share the vol 2 JP BD though? Somebody uploaded vol 1 a few days ago but not vol 2.
Aronz
what if happened the producers say like this… my stuff are leaked in pt tracker so i wont produce any more…? did that bother you sound like you guys saying exactly like this
grow up Private trakies, your reasons are meaning less
and as long as if have physical BD there is no problem in HDD Crash
valid
@Scoped
i see no reasons yet. just the same old screeching and saying that people should respect the exclusivity but no one has explained why they upload something as exclusive. i want to know the actual reason… something like you having stolen them and getting into problems if caught will do. i simply want to know the actual reason not see the same protectionism bullshit
Interruptor
Based, private trackoids are seething in the comments. Keep sharing everything comrade. I will download NOT ONE of your releases but nevertheless, I appreciate the altruism.
B-BUT PEOPLE WILL STOP UPLOADING IF YOU KEEP LEAKING STUFF!!! IT’S NOT RIGHT! Lol thiefs arguing about morality, cry me a fucking river.
Scoped
@ShinningFinger @valid
I don’t get how you guys don’t understand it’s as simple as “I don’t want it on Nyaa” being the reason.
Archer0034
@Scoped Lol you can’t even call that a reason.
valid
@Scoped
but why dont you want? simply saying that you dont want is not a reason
KaoriScarlet1997
@ShinningFinger (There is no merit in sharing BDMV’s for the uploader). The only reason they in general upload is so that someday they can download it back after some years just in case they lose the physical/software copy. In order to have this privilege of accessing a larger online HDD which is the tracker, they have to share it with other people.
In private trackers there are limited people but almost all of them seed and share their BDMV’s and store it for a long time but in public trackers people just download and dont bother to seed and hence the torrent doesnt last long and their whole motive of uploading is lost.
Why not in public trackers? (Almost) no one is interested to share something they bought with their own money especially to people who dont have the courtesy to store it and repay the uploader back by seeding it for them someday, but in private trackers, all the users are FORCED to do so and thats the difference. THE UPLOADER WOULD RATHER SHARE IT WITH LESS AMOUNT OF PEOPLE WHO ARE FELLOW UPLOADERS AND UNDERSTAND EACH OTHER ( OR FORCED TO ) AND SEED RATHER THAN UPLOADING IT TO A PLACE WHERE LARGE AMOUNT OF PEOPLE ONLY DOWNLOAD AND DONT BOTHER DOING THEIR PART ( BECAUSE THEY ARE NOT FORCED TO).
Im not saying public trackers are bad but not everybody uploads just so that other people can enjoy it. They also want something back and thats something they might not get here. Guess that clears some doubts but its your choice to upload and risk not getting new BDMV’s.
XRA9
itt: sense of entitlement through the roof
Aronz
Private trackies HUMBLE REQUEST Please Don’t spoil this comment section. you have already stated your reason Each and Every thing you guys said is same over and over by adding some extra lines.
@ShinningFinger if you are seeing this please don’t replay anymore . no matter what you replay this PTrackies criticize it with meaningless reason , let stop this for better
HiggerNunter
@KaoriScarlet1997, so basically:
Private Trackers: users are accountable to seed/re-seed/upload.
Public Trackers: users aren’t accountable to anything.
TGminer
I was going to watch a three-hour season finale of a reality show, but this comment thread is gold. Thanks!
Abunja
Will check this back tomorrow. Good night, guys.
KaoriScarlet1997
@HiggerNunter Yes, basically. Advantage for uploader - Almost 100% chance of seeing his/her torrent active after 10 years. You might be forced to share with some people, but with the advantage of viewing other BD’s you dont find normally and having a large online free HDD.
jyal
then explain to me if torrent active after 10 years why next torrent not only dead but no longer available :-
[BDMV][最后大魔王][Demon King Daimao][DISC*2 Fin][BDMV(美版)][USA][62G]
[BDMV][花冠之淚][Tears to Tiara][BDMV][美版][USA][80G]
[BDMV][狐妖×仆][Inu × Boku SS][BDMV][美版][USA][62G]
[BDMV][我的朋友很少][Haganai s1][僕は友達が少ない][USA][55.9G]
[BDMV][野良神][Noragami s1][ノラガミ][USA][70.5G]
[BDMV][滑头鬼之孙][Nura: Rise of the Yokai Clan s1][BDMV][美版][USA][138G]
KaoriScarlet1997
@jyal The keyword is almost 100%. Among 1000’s of torrents, you are bound to find some here and there but compare it to here and you will see a HUGE difference. This is considering the fact that there are atleast 10 to 20 times more users on nyaa then PT’s.
MrDeadpool
@ShinningFinger Radiant Season 1 and 2
if u can
HiggerNunter
@KaoriScarlet1997 but the question still remains.
Edit: Regarding this whole leak. Because, personally, there doesn’t seem a concrete reason except “respect the uploader” and “the uploader does not want it public”.
KaoriScarlet1997
@HiggerNunter Which question? I have answered everything if you read my reply well enough.
FLCL4ME
lol you all are acting like this torrent will be here in a few hours and that this guy wont be banned from the private trackers he leaked from
surume
@NiTr0gLiTcH
I was a gold and silver ADC user and I always shared and seeded for more than 10 years. The truth is that many of us never liked that stupid policy of u2. If you upload something to the network, no one prevents someone else from downloading it and uploading it again in another place, it is the risk you take.
@ShinningFinger
thanks but consider snk better than evangelion hahaha. if you don’t have the dvd version, a friend is asking me and luckily I bought 10 blank 50gb bluray discs to burn it
fuee
damn what a fcking dck of a human being
NiTr0gLiTcH
@surume
i never marked my stuff as exclusive and sometimes i find it fun to go hunting the places they got reposted xD
i’m just not interested in wasting the bandwidth of my server on public trackers, since people just hit n run and i’d have nothing in return. but i really dont care if someone reposts something since what u give to the internet belongs to the internet.
that being said, if someone wants their stuff to be exclusive, that’s fine, let’s all respect that since they’re making a huge gift to the community.
PTs aren’t impossible to get in, u can join one for free just by dont being a dick to others (and not totally braindead obv)
fact is, this dumbass isn’t just reposting what he shouldn’t have, he’s insulting the uploaders he’s stealing from too, rising up all the idiots this public tracker can offer.
kinda disgusting tbh
friendevil22
there are many reasons to not release it on public trackers especially nyaa and here are some:
1_ ungrateful idiots who complain
2_ give it 4-5 months and you wont find a seeder
3_ Privacy and making sure people who can afford it to buy it
4_ cant be tracked as easily as public torrents
Anyways before releasing it, you must ask for permission from the uploader himself unless it is anonymous and can’t be tracked
cazador1337
Probably you guys forget about that day when DMCA-chan killed nyaa and you, a bunch of scums, start running to privates trackers.
LightArrowsEXE
Nyaa was never taken down for DMCA’s. Last Nyaa was taken down on the original owner’s volition because he didn’t want to deal with it anymore.
LeVvE
@ShinningFinger Hunter x Hunter USBD is one I’ve been looking for, it’s 600GB+ and I can’t find it anywhere where I got access, if you could put it up here then I’ll love you forever.
randompopcorn
@Dmonhiro, I call forth you to join the conversation, I believe this is a place you would like, yee-haw. Although I disagree with this uploader downplaying the original uploader, how about this, if you spread it on public, more people could have it, occasionally, you might even come across some kind samaritans seeding stuffs with their seedbox, in a way it helps retention in the long run. All arguments who is all for respecting the original uploader’s wish to not repost could be summarised as, keep that particular PT important, and the uploader guaranteed special status, it’s not good for the pt ecosystem in the long run if the massive uploader throw temper tantrum and threaten not to upload blax3. there’s no right and wrong in this regard, relax buddies. imo, so long the uploaded content are not profitised in any manner, it is fine, doesnt necessarily mean money, could be some elitist forum bonus points or other private trackers’ incentives. Now, I definitely do not think shiningfinger get anything in return apart for posting on nyaa from the good name of playing robin hood.
Aronz
@NiTr0gLiTcH just pretend this is not uploaded here
why do you care so much is this your release…?
show producers have not worried this much if you don’t like public why are you here …?
and also you PRIVATE TRACKIES can risk your account invite over greed . don’t you have sense what you are saying. selling invite is also prohibited in Private tracker but you guys don’t follow that.
if you’re that much follower of private tracker rules follow this to…
first you follow the rules completely and speak about the uploader respect
you Private trackies we all know what you guys do to cheat ratio .you all find the source from public and match the hash and data with nfo and upload it to get credit. just don’t pretend to be a saint
what you all saying is meaning less if you are the original content owner i totally agree with you
but here the situation is you have already uploaded in private tracker before without taking ownership and judging with meaning less reason . if you don’t want this here simple don’t look here. whether it’s in public or private you can access there . because if you are true follower of private tracker ,you don’t download from public and you have code of conduct for seed also your site restrict new users. so stop worry and grow up
FLCL4ME
@cazador1337 what no comeback? you let “scum” make you look dumb so you must be below scum? :(
and to everybody requesting stuff it wont be filled because he will be banned before the end of the day so dont get your hopes up
DmonHiro
Man, the fun always starts without me.
Actually, nothing there for me. My position is simple: I love people who upload stuff, but at the same time, I hate those who ONLY upload to private trackers. It would cost them nothing to upload it to Nyaa after the private tracker, but then they wouldn’t be able to hold it over the heads of the plebs. Still, I will obey a request to not upload to public trackers.
FLCL4ME
@Aronz I promise I am not insulting you but can you reword or rephrase that im not sure what you are trying to convey
SeaSmoke
I only managed to read half of @Aronz message. Pls dude, if you have so much to say, at least say it in a way so that others can understand what you’re saying.
NiTr0gLiTcH
@Aronz chill, i’m here as a fansubber, coz this is what public trackers are meant to.
reposting stuff to PTs makes sense since u keep alive torrents that would die out on public ones, but u get barely nothing for ur ratio, since promotions are only on selfrips/dumps and people directly hash what they already downloaded so u don’t even reach half of the filesize of ratio.
anyways, what u brought up wasn’t the point of this discussion in the first place.
FLCL4ME
@Aronz im sure he is as untouchable as the last 2 people who leaked stuff from PT who were then banned by the guy I contacted :P
Aronz
@NiTr0gLiTcH for the contribution to community as fansubber i respect you sir
sorry not here for an argument . ShinningFinger is not getting any thing uploading it here so alteast i am supporting for his contribution. because what he done benefit people who can’t afford seedbox and no access to private tracker still want to watch their favorite show
SeaSmoke
The autism in this section is intense, this’ll probably get sanitised too
valid
@FLCL4ME
i will never understand these whiteknighting assholes :D
Ingenioussubs
@NiTr0gLiTcH
This is the most retarded conversation I have ever seen. What the actual fuck. Wait. Who openly calls themselves a fansubber. I would never do that unless I needed to.
Glordit
lmao looks like 3 other users tossed this thread into the wayback machine already.
Ingenioussubs
@Glordit
Obviously. Imma html this. This shit is gonna be sanitized. CheekyKoala is coming.
NiTr0gLiTcH
@Ingenioussubs
i don’t quite get it, i’m a jp-ita translator during my freetime and i’m not payed a penny for it, i’m doing the stuff i like from zero.
how should i call myself? lol
Ingenioussubs
@NiTr0gLiTcH
Nothing against that. Just something I wouldn’t do. Sorry if that was misinterpreted, or I came off as condescending. btw this has 101 comments now lmfao.
valid
and bt is an open protocol so if you are going to break rules then you can use lots of methods that help getting as much data as possible before they catch you :D
Anon-the-Faithful
These comments are better than anime.
cazador1337
@Aronz report who is selling that invites, because neither AB and U2 allow it
surume
hahaha I remember when I entered the u2 community and raised the idea of having at least 3 months exclusive of there releasing the bdmv.
mistake everyone reminded me of my mother I went out and took out the entire collection of ghibli and the 18 or 20 bdmv of larc n ciel.that i had upload it. I have the kimetsu yaiba all on disk but I can’t upload it because I’m living now in an apartment with shared wifi dog life
KaiDubs
in reply to the uploader’s question: https://pastebin.com/aPXBuMNw
jyal, you could try coordinating with some US Uploader. You cover cost, they order and rip and share. (That is, if all you want is for those BDMVs to be posted.)
Not sure where you got that from. Looks like no one has requested an invite at cost. (Which is against private tracker rules btw)
I’ve only ever seen someone ask (at cost) for an invite once, and they offered $20, not $130, lol.
Also holy shit. #10 most commented on Nyaa now… wtf.
https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1258332
Don’t need to upload something, already uploaded.
KaiDubs
And a last reason someone just asked me to mention: nyaa re-uploaders tend to retag/refolder/completely restructure/detag the uploads and don’t credit.
Sometimes even acting like it’s their own. Although, on this particular note, it’s not limited to nyaa, I’ll say. This would also form as a reason for having specific tracker exclusivity, as people love to mirror to another private tracker and restructure it and call it their own.
NoobSubs
SAVING THIS SHIT!!!
Ingenioussubs
Wow. This is beyond me. Take a break for 4 hours and look what happens. This is nothing but mere insanity. Welcome to the world of nyaa.
xCryptic
we did it fam
we got this torrent to #1 comments for torrents tagged bdmvs
congrats, appreciate all of your efforts
bloop inbound, kinda
Ingenioussubs
Send the bloop lol. Imma save this shit before the mods purge it. People are just gonna add comments at this point. Argument is dead now.
rozee
I hope someday PT was dead, Nyaa was Shutdown, I became rich and then buy Blu-rays by myself.
ReshibanGaming
Nice
_shark
may original uploaders e-penis remains erect forever
saringan_slayer
If Nyaa’s BDMV uploaders uploaded BDMV their BDMV later uploaded in other private anime trackers & we see that for Lupin the nerd whose all BDMV’s were uploaded later by private trackers uploaders but I don’t see the problem of the opposite but even if someone become unsecure then whatever it’s better to respect ones choice i.g. It’s just that one needed to be open minded for a largest anime community which inspire us to support it & do for it.
And last or fast Nyaa is exceptional on it’s terms unlike other PT’s cause ratio isn’t everything.
Ingenioussubs
As long as these leaks are happening, this will never stop. Enjoy the insanity folks… This BDMV that has the most comments as of now.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@xCryptic
If you bloop this I’ll add it to the post description so that everyone can see it without going through this ridiculous comment section
iWednesday
:GWmythsBlobGlare:
surume
@KaiDubs hhhaah ok it had passed me anyway u2 should die now
NoobSubs
Please make more leaks happened. Let the masses enjoy BDMVs instead of just the “elite” groups.
Ingenioussubs
Make more leaks happened.
CptJackSparrow
Can you please upload this:
Ninja Slayer from Animation ニンジャスレイヤー フロムアニメイシヨン BDMV 1080p DISCx2 Fin USA 66.465 GiB
deadman80
Looks at my bookshelf
Someday, I should learn how to rip BDs and increase the size of my seedbox. >.>
Aronz
@KaiDubs
with all respect sir, tracker business happening outside recently . i have solid proof for that but i am not gonna share that because it affect others to…
i know all the trusted sellers. (Which is against private tracker rules)
Abunja
I just wanna leave my two cents while it’s hot:
The OG uploader had made a conscious decision to put this on a PT which I believe that they wanted this to be still ‘shareable’ in years to come, since all PTs (for all I know) requires you to seed (or meet a certain up/down ratio) before downloading another title. Repeat that cycle and it will make an environment of live torrents. This is why most leechers see them as elitists since they seem to have access to exclusive content, which in reality most of this ‘contents’ were dead in public trackers.
I can’t blame them since I believe most of them bought those BDMVs with their hard-earned money, and would share only to people who’d really care about those releases because nobody within a PT would download a gajillion bytes of anime that have no intention of seeding it or it’ll take a huge hit on their up/down ratio. What I see with the guy who leaked these BDMVs is making an ass move. ‘Sharing’ in a public tracker is just a pretense, especially when it comes to torrents with huge files such as BDMVs. I don’t know if this guy is doing this for fame or whatever, but if it’s ‘sharing is caring’ then a site full of leechers isn’t the place for it. It’s like tossing a piece of meat on a pack of hungry wolves and expecting them to share it to everyone.
With all this being said, does this mean I care? Not really. I just hate this guy’s guts. Even it’s ironic to talk about morals when it comes to pirating, the very decision to upload this only to a PT means it only wanted it there, and it should be respected. Unless permitted to share it elsewhere, then it’s a completely different story.
Abunja
Still, this guy can leak all anime from there wherever and whenever he wants. Even though this is a public tracker, somebody in some corner of this world might dedicate itself to seed this for some time. But does this mean it’s a good thing? I don’t really know. I just don’t want to deal with the repercussions if ever things go awful. As some people here pointed out, there are instances that uploaders might not want to upload anymore. And me as a fan of free shared content (aka fellow leecher), would be sad if that day ever comes.
Sts115
ADC is dead, let it leak!
Ingenioussubs
Good grief.
Interruptor
There are not only leechers here though, and as far as public trackers go Nyaa is one of the best all-around for content retention. I still fail to see any decent argument as to why more people shouldn’t have access to this.
Glordit
What from I can gather, it seems like who ever purchases it, seems to think that they have the right to dictate to others what they can and cannot do with it. Good luck with that, specifically on the internet.
HiggerNunter
Congrats y’all. In less than 24 hours, we’ve reached Top 5 of most commented torrent on Nyaa.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
I agree with Glordit, the bullshit reasoning of “public trackers don’t seed” is reasoning thought up by 12 year olds who don’t realize you can upload to private AND public trackers at the same time with different torrents, effectively leaving the public tracker to maintain their own version apart from the private one.
Their argument for this not existing on public trackers is BS, just ignore them.
jyal
@KaiDubs i will be more than happy to send fund to buy new anime but this is public comment i don’t see opion of PM ???
i can setup a dummy email and post it here and if someone in the u.s willing to (buy rip upload) can contact me i will send through paypal…
BUT HOW DO I KNOW THAT THE MONEY WENT TO THE RIGHT PERSON ???
i have to wait to see if the BD is uploaded and if not in month i can open dispute but since this is not a purchase i can’t get my money back…
zrdb
Jesus fucking christ-who really gives a shit about something that was posted on a private tracker being leaked because it was “exclusive”? When you get right down to it if you upload a bd or even a lowly dvd it’s fucking illegal according to any copyright law you can think of. Point is some people who upload stuff do it to stroke their ego, some actually want to share it with others but most do it for a mixture of reasons. My position is if somebody uploads something it should be available to anybody who wants download it. All the “hit and run” people who download stuff and don’t seed it for even a short while should just go die a horrible death.
Archer0034
Adding another comment so that this becomes #2 most commented post and everyone can see this shitshow
Aronz
i don’t think private torrent have that much lifespan. i have seen many torrents posted are (2 and half years before) dead already
noZA_
@Glordit I’ve wrote this before on other BDMV torrents bitching about this same topic and by observation seems that to some of these BDMV sharers at least it’s all about their damn ego and control.
Perhaps it goes deep that they don’t got it in RL or lack it, so this is their spot to shine. Why else would some stop sharing just 'cuz it’s out to the public?
So to them stop bullshitting and get to the point of your whining that it’s about your ego and you want to dictate how you want things to go.
It should be a good thing folks want your shit elsewhere than where you intended. That should fill your belly with some ego juice. And if the seeders don’t keep up the seeding on public trackers that just makes ya’ll on the private trackers more reliable overall and feel free to gloat then.
You whiteknight bootlickers in the comments make me sick sticking up for these BDMV exclusive guys.
@ShinningFinger Keep the shine goin.
sameer
only the cream of the private trackers will have that lifespan.
i can see all pvt tracker potential leeches flocking to the public torrent, not that it should matter much if he doesn’t care
ShinningFinger (uploader)
Will do, amazing words of encouragement, thank you for the only explanation I have gotten here that makes sense.
More leaks coming, just waiting for the Attack on Titan season 1 to have enough completed downloads to be able to allocate bandwidth to others.
_shark
Abunja
Almost always the case. Few dedicate their bandwidth to seed a ginormous file like a BDMV, with most of them don’t even use their own resource (workplace servers and ISP), which also usually don’t last for too long. Unlike private trackers, every one has to seed since it’s obligatory.
That’s the case. The uploader made a conscious decision that they didn’t want to share it to public because they very well know that public trackers are full of leechers. At least if you upload something in a private tracker, if you want to own it then you’re obligated to share it. How hard was it for you to realize that? Call it their ego or whatever, but you coming here acting high and mighty like you made something righteous and talking shit on them doesn’t make you any better. At least the uploader actually bought it, which is good for the industry. You? Nah.
Aronz
let me clear the statement, you all private trackies saying public torrent wont seeded for long run. so uploader worries about his data loss and uploaded in to private tracker instead of public tracker for long run and in case of future use
what i don’t understand private tracker uploaders wont upload after it is leaked ,at the time he has no worries of data loss (HDD crash or Physical disk damage)!!!
what is this doesn’t make any sense…
paoalmyros
The uploaders, who said that they will stop sharing, if they torrent leaks, they don’t care to redownload it again in the future if they lose it. If they stop sharing all the torrents, they will be the only ones that have them, so they will not find them anywhere to redownload it. So the point that they uploading only pt, because they won’t it for a future redownload and they will stop it if leaks anywhere is stupid
jeebs10
I hope you are happy with what you have accomplished here.
By breaking rules regarding exclusive content, whether you agreed with them or not, you have lost the ability to both enjoy exclusive content for yourself, and share non-exclusive content (the vast majority) with others.
Not only that, but your incessant insults have caused uploaders who previously uploaded non-exclusively and didn’t care where the content was shared, to now become PT exclusive uploaders, depriving public trackers of even more content.
So enjoy sharing the 6TB of old content you were able to snatch. It has cost the community you were attempting to benefit more than you know. Some hero.
tomyud
internet speeds are improving every year. no reason to not upload to public trackers. the whole point of uploading something is to share it with other people.
KaiDubs
#3 now… jesus.
I gave you reasons as you requested, not just “becuz i say.” or other short worded/no detail as others have, but various reasons all in detail, but seems you ignored it.
https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1273100#com-106
ThePi7on
Uhm, well I’ll throw this out there since there seem to be people interested in crowdfunding here.
I just finished releasing MHA season 3 a while ago, and with a group of people I’m currently planning to crowdfund season 4 too.
If you’re interested in helping, feel free to check out my latest upload for more info. Peace ✌️
SeaSmoke
@Interruptor see this, it was uploaded just 1 month ago and was downloaded by 86 people, and it’s already dead. In contrast, see this, it’s a 4 year old upload, and yet it has 8 seeders out of which the 3 I connected to were seedboxes which instantly maxed out my download speed. Public trackers are shit in terms of retention.
I’m not in U2, and primarily depend on people sharing BDMVs to Nyaa for my own encodes. However, what you’re doing is already causing more and more people to stop uploading to Nyaa, and then there’s guys who have stopped uploading to PTs as well and now directly share their BDs with people they know and trust. You’re attempting to make BDs publicly available, but you’re actually pushing other BDMV providers away from sharing.
As for exclusive releases, I personally don’t agree with it and don’t see any point in doing that, but in the end they’re the ones who paid for it and bought it, if they don’t want to share it publicly, can’t you just respect their wishes? If you disagree with them, just buy it yourself and share it publicly. That’s what Lupin was doing, but he got pissed off by guys like you. He was buying BDs himself and uploading, but other leakers started keeping tabs on his purchases and started leaking stuff which he was buying for uploading to Nyaa. So not only did you manage to piss off PT exclusive uploaders, you also managed to piss off public uploaders at the same time.
paoalmyros
It seems that people forget, that piracy is for some people to help other people to get something, that they can’t get it or make it, like buy BDMV or encode or sub it. They are doing this because they care for the others and want to help them. But some people in pt only care for theirselfs and they think they are gods and they don’t want plebs to have their files
Scully_
@SeaSmoke I will reseed it for a week…
jyal
@ThePi7on i see you only upload jap not USA BD…
SeaSmoke
@Scully_ Nah I got a USBD from somewhere, so I don’t need that rn, but it’s stupid how people think public trackers are good for retention when 99.8% of the people here immediately remove the torrent after completion. I doubt that any of the guys who keep saying “please leak more PT BDMVs” ever actually seed the bdmvs they download. As of today I’ve got 1.6TB upload in the last 20 days just from seeding nyaa stuff. I don’t even have a seedbox, im doing it off a 100mbps home connection, but most of the time I end up being the last or one of the last few people seeding. It just baffles me how entitled some people can be when they contribute absolutely nothing themselves.
ThePi7on
@jyal
Yes, that’s because encodes sourcing the USBDs are already out there.
I’m looking to release JP BDs because they’re a better quality source, meaning they could spawn even better encodes.
And for the people that care about english dub, it can always be muxed in once we have a JP-sourced encode :)
Scully_
i’ve got 40TB upload in the past 15 days just from seeding nyaa stuff for maximum one week. And a week later there are almost no more seeders.
SeaSmoke
@ThePi7on Zanros released his hybrid remux 4 days ago, with video from your JPBDs and audio from his USBDs
SeaSmoke
Scully_ yeah Ik, if I had a better connection my upload would be a lot more. Mine basically uploads at max speed for the entire day (since my PC is on 24/7), sometimes it feels good to be helping out, but when everyone just leeches and doesn’t seed for even a second it starts to piss me off. I actually had the bikini warriors bdmv seeding when it had like, 3 - 6 seeders. I saw someone start to download from me, and at that time there was only one leecher. Two days later I see the completed count up by one but seeders was still that same :/ whoever it was didn’t even seed it for a minute.
ThePi7on
@SeaSmoke
Oh, good to know!
Is it on nyaa tho? Can’t find it
SeaSmoke
No it’s not, afaik Zanros uploads exclusively to AnT, but almost everything he posts gets leaked at some point.
jyal
@ThePi7on
yeah, but i was following on KaiDubs suggesting that instead of me buying and paying for extra shipping and waiting for 45-60 day, i could send fund for someone with free and fast shipping in the u.s to buy-rip-upload the BD that on the list…
i’m only interesting in USA BD…
I can always download JP BD and remux with english audio but not interesting in that because there always room for error and i need to rewatch and to make sure audio and sub are sync and often if there diffrent ver or somthing is cut you need to edit…
only untouched USA BD…
Scully_
@SeaSmoke he also upload to BHD and Blutopia
noZA_
@Abunja High and mighty and righteous? What are you going on about? The uploader made it plain and clear. Provide a reasonable reply on why people like the uploader should stop sharing “exclusive” stuff to the public or go watch your Commie subs dude.
@jeebs10 Oh my, are you aware there are websites out there that grab these “exclusives” (and they have invites to these PT’s) put up links to get paid off per download but a place like nyaa where it’s freely offered receive the backlash by whiteknight bootlickers “oh no you vile beasts how dare you taint and defile the integrity of our BDMV exclusive overlord’s”.
Calling out the BS reasoning are not insults. You two get over yourselves.
@SeaSmoke smh. I can play that game too, here’s Kizumonogatari https://nyaa.iss.one/view/986258 and here’s Evangelion 1.11 https://nyaa.iss.one/view/67241 Here’s another one still seeding, Serial Experimental Lain https://nyaa.iss.one/?f=0&c=0_0&q=bdmv+lain What’s the next argument? It’s because Popularity > Ecchi? There are more seeded BDMV’s on the site from the days of the original nyaa to the current one. I think somebody wrote above on PT there are some not seeded.
Lupin said the reason and it was for wasting his time and money (that and shitposters) despite having listed what he was planning. Either the folks unintentionally released stuff like that Goblin Slayer movie or they did it on purpose I am not certain but it’s for those reasons and not what you wrote. Try a different angle in your next attempt to validate BDMV PT sharers.
SeaSmoke
The guy who said PTs have unseeded torrents is on 0 PTs, he’s just talking out of his ass. I saw him comment on another release about how these leakers are good for people like him who don’t have access to PTs, so I dunno how he’s keeping track of the seed status on PTs if he’s not actually in them. I’m yet to find a torrent unseeded on any anime PT, and even if it is, PTs have reseed requests which actually work, so everyone who downloaded it gets a message that someone needs a reseed (as opposed to leaving comments here which no one reads). I had asked for a reseed req on a music tracker and someone was up to seed it within an hour. People on PTs are really nice in that sense.
Wow those torrents have some really nice seeds, I just added it to a shared seedbox and im getting some glorious speeds on them. 600KBps on Kizu with spikes to 1.5MBps, and Lain barely going on at 100KBps. Eva is well seeded tho, gotta give it that.
As for lupin, this is what he said. Seems pretty obvious to me that he’s pissed off at leakers, but if im misinterpreting something then please do explain.
noZA_
Are you on other PT’s? You already stated you’re not on U2 so how do you know that? I dunno who said it anyways, not gonna read all the above comments just to find out.
The original nyaa had some cool feature where if somebody made a comment you’ll receive a message and a link to the exact torrent it was made at. It could of been on either your own torrents or (or both) comment on another’s torrent. There’s been comments on stuff I’ve shared that I didn’t realize were made months ago. So a feature like that would be good especially for those asking for a seed request.
I dunno how you get leakers from that when a comment later he elaborates further and he does make a good point there but that’s what happens when taking requests from leechers. This topic is about those marked with exclusive to PT being shared elsewhere.
SeaSmoke
not on U2, but I didn’t say U2 I said anime PTs in general. I recently got in. The feature you mention has been a request on the nyaa github for years, but it was never implemented. I don’t think current admins plan on adding it. It would be useful tho.
cazador1337
I think this place can be wonderful if everyone share at least what they have downloaded a ratio of 1:1… but since no one cares about it, why I should care too? About leaks who cares? This torrent will be dead after some time… like almost every torrent here.
noZA_
@---------------- feeling special now? I know I am my mom told me.
AvrilLavigne
Private trackers provide benefits, biggest being access to rarer content. Those benefits are why people are willing to buy their BDs and rip them then upload them there. They’re not doing it out of the kindness of their heart; private trackers provide benefits that the purchaser/ripper/uploader sees as compensation for what they’ve done. Public trackers don’t do that. We see it right here–why aren’t you buying the BDs yourself and ripping them then uploading here? You’re doing a low effort thieving job for everyone out of the kindness of your heart, but are you willing to purchase, rip and upload here out of the kindness of your heart? No, didn’t think so.
Things are then preferred to be kept on private trackers because the more exclusive content that exists on private trackers, the more benefits there are for people that are on those sites and so more reason for them to go out and buy BDs then rip them.
If I join U2 for example and I see there’s a BDMV I really want but I don’t have the required upload data to DL that safely for my ratio, my best way to build my ratio would be to upload things that aren’t there–usually things nobody has bought, ripped and uploaded to the internet yet. However, if I was to find everything I need on public trackers, I’ll never have that incentive to buy, rip and upload things myself in order to access these things I want.
This is really simple shit to understand as long as you don’t have the brain of a communist.
LightArrowsEXE
An appendum to Avril’s post, since he didn’t cover it: There’s also time-limited freeleeches on the site to incentivise people to download more releases to seed. If it was purely ratio-based, the average ratio would always have to be a perfect 1, but with freeleech people can get additional stuff to seed without compromising their own ratio.
AvrilLavigne
FL isn’t worth talking about imo–varies from site to site. ADC for example only used to have it like once a year.
LightArrowsEXE
Fair enough, might just be the specific trackers I’ve been active in then. I never really used ADC since u2 had everything I needed at the time.
Aronz
you fellow private trackies think you are only ones who own private world.then i am saying you are wrong we all know what PTT world looks likes we served at some point
unlike you sure we have limited resources , doesn’t mean we don’t know nothing about PTT
still PT trackerists failed to submit the vailid reasons. all i can see you all talking about seeders and leechers like rocket science
but judging from your fact all i can see is selfishness( NOT EVERY ONE I HAVE SEEN MANY GOOD PEOPLES TO),
all i can see from the bottom of the heart you are afraid of not getting resources.
still i am not against any PTT ,lot of people have benifit from there to…
remember one thing world belongs to everyone.
i know some people don’t like the idea to keep everything on private ,but they have no choice, so they agree PTT eventually
Abunja
@noZA_ Do you even read? It’s clear that this BDMV was intended to be uploaded and shared to private trackers only. The only reason I see that they don’t want to put this to public trackers is because they don’t want to share it with leechers which is totally reasonable. If you ever buy a BDMV collection, will you share it to people who are willing to share the same passion as you, or will you to those people that just wanted it for themselves? And who’s acting all high and mighty by dissing the people from where it was stolen, calling them elitists and whatnot? Definitely not me.
PS: Commie releases were most of the time better than your untranslated Japanese cartoons.
Abunja
@Aronz to a common leecher, all they can see are private tracker users being selfish themselves. What you are failing to see is that how their environment works. Even within, you can’t still download anything if you don’t have a positive up/down ratio. You still have to seed so the others can have their fair share. Have you ever looked at yourself in a mirror whenever you kill a torrent after finishing downloading it and ask yourself if “am I not being selfish?”
NoobSubs
Like you guys said, public trackers are full of leechers: “it was uploaded just 1 month ago and was downloaded by 86 people, and it’s already dead.” so why WOULD YOU PEOPLE CARE IN THE FIRST PLACE?! If the torrent is going to die in a few months anyways, it shouldn’t matter if it’s upload here. Only a couple hundred people (max) will download it because not everyone has terabytes of space for BDMVs anyway then, the torrent is history.
It doesn’t effect private trackers and they resume their exclusivity plus it benefits encoders that can download it within that small time frame to give us more anime.
Aronz
@Abunja modern problem requires modern sollution Thats why PTT exit
aleast you all are saying that public torrent wont last for a month
so consider it’s a free opportunity for the people who can’t afford seed box and no access to PTT and admit it , there is no problem i can see in that
people in PTT eventually seed more than ten years,so give this small time frame as a courtesy to others ,don’t be too selfish
not everyone download bdmv, this also benfit the births of new fansubbers who have passion in it so they can experiment on these resources
Even big companies gives free opportunity to every one sometimes, so why can’t you…?
Archer0034
While I do support the idea of sharing BDMVs with everyone, leechers here on nyaa really are assholes. 7 people finished downloading and only 1 seeder (probably the uploader himself) when the torrent was posted just yesterday.
valid
@SeaSmoke
https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1273100#com-162
dont forget that most private trackers prune dead torrents to make their stats look nicer. torrents do die even on the best private trackers but of course not as much as they do on public trackers
SeaSmoke
That’s obvious, no one is going to seed something forever. But on PTs all you need to do is pop by the forums and ask for it, and if someone has it they’ll often upload stuff. The image some people are creating over here is that PTs are run and used by demonic people who care about nothing but their own epeen, which is not true. People on PTs are generally much more friendlier and willing to help out than guys over here.
cazador1337
prune means they try to hide it but don’t delete it, you can see it and reseed that again. Is different from what you @valid say.
valid
@SeaSmoke
many pt uploaders are motivated by the economy and user classes but its true that they arent all just assholes who dont want to share. the exclusive uploaders are actually a small minority of the trackers and most have no problem with their uploads getting shared by others
valid
@cazador1337
what they do depends on the tracker but many do actually delete the torrent if it has been dead few weeks. it can always be reuploaded if someone wants to but you have to fill in all of the metadata in the upload form again because its not on their servers anymore
saringan_slayer
@valid currently 90% Guys who put Exclusive tag on their BDMV release on private trackers are from USA or one who releases USA BDMV’s.
Ingenioussubs
noZA_
@Abunja It’s clear you don’t read and understand the replies since then. Too busy projecting what you wanna see throwing around “elitist” as if it was being used often when only 1 person besides you has use the word. Still continuing this high and mighty nonsensical talk too, smh. How the hell do you “steal” something that somebody already bought, ripped and was shared to the internet? Baffling.
Bad news for you Abunja, I’ve shared BDMV and DVDISO under anon. Music too under this account without a single mention it’s from my collection with the exception of one. Now where will you go?
Hmm. See’s what you got: https://nyaa.iss.one/user/Abunja
Unless you’ve done it under anon, crickets.
When are you gonna share something? Let’s be real how many torrents do you keep alive? Everything you’ve downloaded since joining nyaa? How many torrents have you killed after finishing downloading?
XRA9
Apology for poor English
When were you when torrent on Niaa dies?
I was sat at home eating smegma butter when Pjotr ring
“torrent is kill”
“no”
GeekWorld
someone insert *MJ eating popcorn* pic here.
XRA9
valid
@noZA_
tfw im probably part of this problem :D
i have shared some personal rips of discs that i have but only on private trackers… none of them are marked exclusive tho so anyone can do whatever they want with them. i just dont want to up to shitty sites like pirate bay which makes money with ads and i also cant up them here because i would be breaking the rules then
GeekWorld
@XRA9… Carry On!! this legacy
Edit : Thanks
Aronz
completed morrons .what you are doing is pure cheating and unacceptable
ShinningFinger risk his neck and dedicated everything for you.he is also ready to fullfill your requests
still you guys don’t seed back what you already obtained
is that the best you can do…?
if you still continue this you have no right to judge for what you are getting…
surume
@noZA_ Your argument is valid, look, I was gold and silver in ADC and we were uploading blurays dvds files for more than 10 years with my hard drive army and some other friends.we received a clear incentive it was from a group that knew us of course it was not much but we bought more material we hated those who upload our material in public tracker. but we also did not realize that there were people who could not access this because of its remoteness and problems and that there will always be someone who will take the material and distribute it everywhere for something the network is free so we stop doing liver and continue with our routine.now that ADC is dead I had to burn everything to discs and format my hard drives, I no longer have time as before, that’s how things are
Aronz
i have seen a valid point Here what if happen your PTT Suddenly disappear…??
This happens before remember the case of ADC
you still have to depend on public at some point
XRA9
>what if happen your PTT Suddenly disappeared…??
Nothing, you just take your stuff to another.
valid
@XRA9
the most dedicated users will up what they have but tons of obscure content may be lost forever when a big tracker closes. it has happened many times before and will happen again some day
Scoped
Half the retards defending this shit can’t even speak English properly lmao
rthrt
usually, the crowd of any product that it attracts says something about the products themselves…
XRA9
@rthrt
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2a1b1/2a1b1c2dd0164cb9db5485a2dc50e142f2d464a0" alt="anime is for"
sameer
XD
Glordit
surume
@valid obscure content?? lmao no those were others that came from asia itself we were more only anime and some concerts there
valid
@surume
its a thing. for example those old animes that are only available in the obsolete divx format
Aronz
@Scoped
as far as you have no valid reason doesn’t matter
XRA9
Again @rthrt
https://live.fundza.mobi/home/fanz/essays/anime-symbolizes-satan/
Scoped
@Aronz
Are you retarded?
The reason of “honouring the providers” is perfectly valid if you’re not a fucking child. Why would you willingly and knowingly piss off the people that provide you content? Why would you go out of your way to give someone a reason to stop uploading? Why would you risk all this shit for some retarded Nyaa-user clout that noone will remember in a month’s time?
valid
@Aronz
i can think of few things but they dont really apply to generic blurays that anyone who has money can buy. some could be custom content and actual leaks(you would basically have to be involved in the industry to do this). anyone who shares such things is basically begging for problems tho… the private trackers may be hard to get to for the average person but its better to assume that malicious people can get in if they really want to
Simplistic
Bruh… is this actually going to pass Dragon Ball
XRA9
Shitpost more and it will.
absinth
Damn this is such a big shitpost now. It took me 25 mins to read through that pepega.
Truth is that you cant always share everything to public means, neither the reason is copyrights or your own sake.
Public anime torrents dosent keep big filesize torrents for long because your avarage viewer that utilizes nyaa has 0 knowledge on using bdmv or dvdiso and would rather download his compressed moozzi2 hevc encode with subs that have honorifics included because filesize is low. (Keep in mind that exception proves the rule, soo the fact that few BDMV’s survived dosent mean every bdmv will survive )
Video quality is not the important part of watching anime anyway (although there are peeps that enjoy having good quality anime).
Is the leaker the bullied one or its right to fuck on him? Personally I would follow the wish of Content Uploader. But as its internet leaks are something normal that happens from time to time, either it is some dumb ecchi anime or user database of big site. Its just how internet works (I find it funny when some priv shit gets leak on other priv site). The whole shitstorm seems like both sides tries to show that their are more right than others but truth is that both sides are floor -1 level and they are going deeper and deeper. Trying hard you can compare Torrent uploader to a guy that uploades anime to youtube, it will die faster or slower depending on what it is, some might survive for very long some might be dead while after uploading.
Is there harm created? I personally think there is no long term harm, maybe some short term harm done to PT’s because the guys that has to enlarge their e pee pee had their “exclusive” (funny word isn’t it?) bdmv leaked soo its just resonable that your “exclusive” pee pee guy wil get mad.
Not marking the original uploader is also a dickmove tho.
Lupin the nerd case feels really out of the place, as it might seem similiar because leaking and shit but the whole thing was more different than the case scenario we have right now.
NoobSubs
Would crediting the original BDMV uploader help in anyway or does it not matter?
[BDMV][USA] Attack on Titan Season 3 = 209 comments
[Pendekar] Dragon Ball - Son Goku Saga [Dragon Box] [Multi Audio] = 218 comments
Let’s do this boys!
XRA9
How would that help? In this case right here, the uploader has been credited and he’s as pissed off as he would’ve been without the credit.
absinth
The only thing that makes me sad is that CheekyKoala will probably delet comment section.
@NoobSubs Its a speedrun to beat top comments we are at 33 hours and 42 minutes.
We are going for World Nyaa Record.
7 comments left to break the WR any% Top Nyaa release by comments.
ThePi7on
Freedom man VS monkey man
who will win
NoobSubs
@XRA9
It’s because he didn’t do it right. What if he said something like, “All Credit goes to Mr. X. I luv u so much boo <3 <3 <3 xxx pls don’t be mad at me it’s all lovee xxxxxx”
@absinth
That’s why you gotta make sure you save it ;)
jyal
i will bet on freemonkey man…
surume
I think this still lasts for a while the fights between public and private come from decades ago
absinth
@NoobSubs ill make sure to save it we are currently at 34h 02m (rough estimation ill calculate the correct value once WR is broken)
@ThePi7on I bet on the “VS” guy
@surume Oh those old times where peeps didnt had nothing to do like we now and just shitstorm about PrivateTracker vs PublicTracker
surume
@absinth
I can imagine those fights between public tracker and private tracker
https://thumbs.gfycat.com/CoordinatedSeparateHellbender-max-1mb.gif
cazador1337
218 OwO
absinth
AND GUYS WE HAVE A RECORD!, IT ONLY TOOK US 1 DAY, 10 HOURS, 16 MINUTES TO BREAK WR OF NYAA TOP COMMENT TORRENT ANY% (34H 16M)
(GOING TO SAVE IT FOR OUR FUTURE GENERATIONS AND POSSIBLE ATTEMPTS TO BREAK IT)
BIG THANKS TO EVERYONE WHO SHITPOSTED HERE.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6a3c9/6a3c977bab687592e692e1955621f368c59249a3" alt="oniichan.please-fuck.me oniichan.please-fuck.me"
matheousse
Thanks to all you guys, we did it. We broke the comments record.
surume
@absinth
good in bdmv category first there was fate heaven feel bdmv with 98 comments and the maximum in sukebei are 66 with fakku’s manga
NoobSubs
God DAMN. Here it is guys, ya broke the Nyaa comment record! Congrats!
Remember guys, all of you who commented are a part of Nyaa history, YOU!!!
I’d like to give a shout-out to my nigga pip3, my nigga charman01, my nigga zMega, my nigga KaoriScarlet1997, my nigga zechs, my nigga valid, my nigga jdcox215, my nigga Glordit, my nigga ChaoXide, my nigga NiTr0gLiTcH, my nigga Aronz, my nigga Jorex342, my nigga skolastico, my nigga Ken-Sama, my nigga areen, my nigga HiggerNunter, my nigga DonCanjas, my nigga CptJackSparrow, my nigga moonship, my nigga jyal, my nigga TGminer, my nigga MrDeadpool, my nigga FLCL4ME, my nigga fuee, my nigga friendevil22, my nigga cazador1337, my nigga LightArrowsEXE, my nigga LeVvE, my nigga randompopcorn, my nigga DmonHiro, my nigga SeaSmoke, my nigga Ingenioussubs, my nigga Anon-the-Faithful, my nigga KaiDubs, my nigga xCryptic, my nigga rozee, my nigga ReshibanGaming, my nigga iWednesday, my nigga surume, my nigga NoobSubs, my nigga deadman80, my nigga Sts115, my nigga Interruptor, my nigga zrdb, my nigga Archer0034, my nigga noZA_, my nigga _shark, my nigga jeebs10, my nigga tomyud, my nigga paoalmyros, my nigga Scully_, my nigga ThePi7on, my nigga AvrilLavigne, my nigga Abunja, my nigga saringan_slayer, my nigga XRA9, my nigga GeekWorld, my nigga rthrt, my nigga sameer, my nigga Scoped, my nigga Simplistic, my nigga absinth, my nigga matheousse, my nigga Ocee, my nigga JhonnySetnom
and lastly: The SUPREME nigga ShinningFinger.
Ocee
clannad torrent died for this
JhonnySetnom
I put my comment in this top now so I can make part of it too. <.<
Ingenioussubs
Cheers. That’s all I have to say to this insanity.
Abunja
@noZA_
I wonder what does this implies? I’ll wait.
The fact that it was uploaded only to a private tracker literally means that its sharing should only be limited to them, at least thru internet. I believe that the uploader decided to share it to them out of their goodwill to show appreciation to the community that they can enjoy anime titles that’s most probably dead on public trackers, while also adding new content for those who are interested in their collection. Leaking content to people who are not the intended audience, in a sense, is akin to stealing. Nothing much different from somebody who pirates, really.
Ooh, such a big boy! What a great contribution to the community, hmm? Let me stroke that e-peen and let’s see how big it got, hmm?
Sorry, but I already mentioned that I am also a leecher in this site. But does that mean I have the right to call everyone who uses private trackers selfish? No. I was once a PT user in bakabt, so I know how most PTs work and also not to be an asshole to the community I’m in. What I don’t understand with you people is how you perceive them like that when you can just act like a normal person and try to get your way in there if you desperately want to get your hands on those ‘exclusive’ contents, rather than dissing them for their ‘exclusive’ nature.
Abunja
Alive torrents? 1887 torrents since March 8, 2017 at a lousy upspeed of 80kbps of home internet, if you insist. If you ask since when I joined Nyaa, that’ll be probably 10 years ago. Old Nyaa died along with my 250GB HDD (RIP). If you ask if I killed something after I finished downloading it? Yes. Those are for non-archive anime that’s also well seeded (HorribleSubs) and also my issue before of limited HD space.
Do you think I need some kind of validation? Or you just wanna flex? Like I said before, I’m trying not to be an asshole to the community that I’m in. As for most entitled people here, that’s pretty much hard to do.
rockleevk
I do keep seeding content that is fanmade for some laughs, like this one over here: https://nyaa.iss.one/view/506129
And wow, that escalated quickly, #1 already on comments.
Lupin the Nerd
Only going to make this one an only comment on this. if you get caught selling invites on many of those trackers they will ban you as that is against the rules for many of those sites,
Glordit
Read this again but, slowly. Then remember what torrenting anime is and what the purpose of this website is.
valid
hit & runs sound like extra work… wouldnt gain anything useful from it so why do it
iWednesday
231
Raiyan23
yay we got a new comment champ
Abunja
@Glordit I know. That’s why it’s hard to talk about ethics here since pirating is morally and legally wrong. That’s why I don’t have any qualms if the OP still decides to upload BDMVs here despite the persuasion of others to not to. I just don’t like it because it’s a scummy and disrespectful. Even somebody decides to put something in the internet doesn’t mean it’s up for grabs for everybody, especially if shared only within a discreet and confined environment. Technically, it’s still stealing. And even what are we doing are wrong, it doesn’t mean that we should aggravate things by doing even more wrong.
noZA_
@Abunja
Irrelevant. I’ve already written down what you were projecting on. You’re just deflecting.
And this…
I’m not gonna even give a reply back to this. The level of absurdity.
As for your attitude that I’m a big boy it appears you may have a memory of a fish seemingly forgetting you asked me if I’ve shared BDMV and I’ve replied back. Here’s what you posted to refresh your memory.
Remember how you told me If I knew how to read? Take your head out of your ass.
As for you seeding once again you seem to have forgotten what you wrote. Your attempt was to shame Aronz by your weak argument concerning killing a torrent by selfishly not seeding back. The fact of the matter is that you yourself kill torrents defeating your own argument.
noZA_
posting such a comment on nyaa… /palm face
racer21
This comment will be my mark on nyaa’s history, although I’m not entirely sure if I want to be part of this stupid circlejerk. ┐( ˘_˘)┌
daswf852
what a shitshow, kek
binomayigu
The entire argument against leaking here is leaks = uploader gets pissed off = no releases in the long run since uploaders have all the power here. Private tracker people want to ensure supply of future releases because uploaders have them by the balls, they treat them like gods because they are willing to buy stuff.
If you want to make the exclusivity irrelevant, go buy things and share them on nyaa. Otherwise, new uploaders will still be stuck with the exclusivity mentality.
Don’t want leaks, organize a small tight-knit group only for buyers like moozzi does.
Aronz
@Scoped
copying same word again and again ,don’t you feel bored by doing this…? atleast change a little bit
just make it simple we all know you don’t like this idea
i don’t disrespect uploaders (whether he is PT or Public)
@Abunja
chill man. i know you are scared ,because you are worried about not getting resources in future most of them are.
but you failing to see the fact is there’s no loss for your orginal uploader .but he still not doing this we agree that
but he also restrict others to not upload here, what he get from that…?
remember we are talking over a pirate content and also i to seed
and you also afraid orginal uploader not going to upload here after, i don’t think he is that much sensitive over a simple matter
LightArrowsEXE
Hi mom
larklen
I’m just here to be here
Ingenioussubs
I’m on cannabis now.
Scyrous
thanks for the free stuff
tyroz
You guys are being fooled! ShinningFinger works for the media business and his mission is to infiltrate private trackers and leak their files so they stop sharing the files they purchased!
Don’t you get that this is a psychological copy protection?!
absinth
@tyroz Hey, Crunchyroll menager here. Please delete this.
NiTr0gLiTcH
go away, crunchy’s a warez
surume
@noZA_
Maybe before we had enough problems to get new material blurays so people gave us an incentive now if you take a tour of the gigantic forums of China and Russia all this material here you will find there complete series uploaded to baidu and other pages everything at hand has already been told to u2 that their exclusivity no longer makes sense in these times or at least lighten their policy but they insist on staying that way How could you talk about stealing if by uploading a bluray you are already stealing from the company unless I give you permission, although that would be impossible /Palm face
jetfire61999
just wording if anyone is goig to do the dragon ball super’s as bdmv
Aronz
This mark #250…
korbaNTR
Thx for made my weekend so alive!
keep going boys.
_Edge_
Get NIIGGA’d @NoobSubs
Koitern
This is exactly the reason why I left U2 or any PT because shitty fucking arguments like these.
I dare any of you assholes to say this to DBZ fans that want those original audios and I promise you they’ll have your PT uploads leaked in less than 1 hour for being a asshole that want to charge money to see it lmaoo. Stop being a fucking retarded private hoarders douches and release them here simple as that or else you have people like OP doing this. And don’t give the the weak argument of “ oh it’s because we need this torrent alive on PT” please shut the fuck up you have no idea what you are saying at that point. Go cry in a corner please you fucking rats.
Nyaa up
Private hoarder douche down.
Yet OP has yet to get a constructive argument of why this wasn’t released to the public in the first place.
XRA9
blackcampaign
without someone to buy, where will you get the BD? armed robbery?
stop acting like Robin Hood
Ingenioussubs
This shitposting will never end.
jillvalentine
@half the people in this comment section
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/62f98/62f984dad937f73faa1492e8ff00cfc44a235257" alt="alt text"
Why is it that the people with broken english always defend this shit? Fucking leeches.
absinth
@blackcampaign This was already disscused, No normal BD provider will quit because of leaks unless he is on PT only to boost his e-pee-pee. Noone normal would quit because you got your shit leaked. Would google stop providing all of the spyware they provide if something got leaked? No. The only point that is valid is the fact that peeps should respect Uploader wish to keep it exclusive to certain PT. (even tho most of the time you can find uploaded on baidu or some russian forum.)
Simplistic
And because seeding BDMVs require decent internet and no data cap to be even worth it, especially when people are going to download it like twice a month
friendevil22
@Koitern You left? they kicked you out… and already gave the reasons, this torrent with the most comments only has 6 S 8 L and 29 Completed Downloads, in a few months this BDMV wont have a single seeder, all you do is bitch and think for yourself “that should make my point valid”, this uploader doesn’t care for the reasons given, he is a troll and having a good time and has no respect for the original uploader.
zrdb
Whassamatter-you people who uploaded to a PT get butthurt because somebody leaked it? Tough fucking shit, life can be a fucking bitch-just deal with it.
blackcampaign
@absinth what? I don’t understand
jyal
@zrdb "ife can be a fucking bitch-just deal with it"
FUCKER LIKE YOU who said i have what you looking for but not going to upload haha…
NOT HARD TO NOT SAY ANYTHING SO SHUT THE FUCKUP…
valid
most bdmvs do indeed die quickly here but for some reason even some really big ones from almost 10 years ago are still seeded. i must have been really lucky too sometimes because i would download a bdmv and after a while i would be the last seed on it
nbdxq
Great comment section here ^.^
Ingenioussubs
Damn guys. This looks like it’ll be the never-ending story. I know the mods don’t even give a shit at this point. This is beyond autistic. Take this crap to Doom9 or somewhere else.
valid
i have always wondered how people set those avatars. theres no button for that anywhere but many seem to have them anyway
azusa_miura
This is the #267 comments.
Keep going y’all
xCryptic
bloop
cazador1337
#270, keep your hard work guys
Mughal125
@ShinningFinger kindly upload Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba and one piece [BDMV][USA]
valid
is that really not here yet
NiTr0gLiTcH
⊳people still asking him bdmvs not knowing he’s been long banned by now, along with the ones who helped him, kek
btw, AoT S3 was the only exclusive he leaked and he was banned for it, all the other bdmvs he posted weren’t exclusive, but just reposts from adc no one bothered to share here (for the reasons explained above).
so this guy bloating his ego and freely insulting around did basically nothing really great, he just reposted a bunch of allowed stuff, calling all the attention on him just like every attention whore would do
tldr: let this die here, he’s going to post the shitton of bdmvs he downloaded before being banned and he’ll go back to his hole
valid
of course its best to follow the sites rules if you want to stay on those sites but the snitches on here are pathetic losers. imagine spending your time looking for leaked exclusives on public sites… not exactly something that a sane person who has a normal life would do :D
cazador1337
surume
@jillvalentine It will be because many or some of us who are not English speakers like me because I am Italian, we are here more brain before saying such nonsense and I am using the google translator lol lol fuk
TheDevilsHyper
uhh can anyone help me I am getting this in VLC “this blu-ray disc will play on region a players only”
zrdb
LOL-italian or not it’s spelled FUCK as in buttfucked, not fuk. This whole thing is a giant travesty, shit-I don’t even like Attack On Titan. Ya’ll should be happy you even get bdmv or iso torrents, I sure am. Hyper-try this. Open up each disc stream folder and look for the largest m2ts files-rename them AOT 3 01 or some such shit and then run them through MKVtoolnix and turn each one into an mkv file. You should be able to play them. BTW-I use VLC as a last resort, better to use either PotPlayer or MPC-HC. Pardon me, I’m gonna go fornicate or something now.
NiTr0gLiTcH
@surume ma se sei italiano che ci fai qui sotto? >_>
hai i bd dynit che son meglio persino dei jp, per SnK (trad della s1 a parte)
Aronz
#280
zrdb
You italian guys are right-in most cases the Dynit blurays are as good or better than the japanese blurays. Why you ask? Simple-the encoders actually give a shit about pq and audio.
NiTr0gLiTcH
^^true, they still have limitations imposed both from the licensor and the japaneses, but they try their best so the result is usually the best source available
ThePi7on
spaghetti gvng rise up?
Aronz
@TheDevilsHyper
Open the VLC Preferences window, select “show settings=ALL” in the lower left corner, then select Input/Codecs -> Access modules -> Blu-ray in the list on the left, and then you can change the player’s default area code.
surume
semplice è collezionabile
thx4memes
thx
bishop_
Lmao it all started with a “Fuck private trackers”. IMO, private trackers do more good than bad all in all
iqfqrzlu
most commented torrent on nyaa in a week ggwp
Ingenioussubs
Most commented post on Nyaa in two days actually.
iElohim
How do I get my own profile picture?
absinth
@Ingenioussubs
Most commented post on Nyaa in 1 day, 10 hours and 16 minutes actually.
ShinningFinger (uploader)
@iElohim
See this: https://nyaa.iss.one/help#avatar
fractalflash7
Just wanted to point out the only comment that made sense to me: https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1273100#com-167
I used to think all these chads painstakingly buying, ripping and uploading BDMVs were doing this out of their generousity. As it turns out, many do it just so they get to be a part of PvTs. This is totally fine(although it does break my illusion), but this is gatekeeping. So, others don’t deserve the HQ stuff just because they can’t seed? Not everyone has the ability to you know? Seeing people’s reaction it feels like leakers are a necessary evil for Private Trackers, just like Piracy itself is.
As pointed out here: https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1273100#com-149, many people pirate out of necessity, not everyone gets to live in a first world country with expendable income. Piracy is about sharing.
The solution to me seems to be Timed Exclusives like mentioned here: https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1273100#com-105. Dedicated uploaders get their ‘fame’ and status in the PvT, rightfully so, while us ‘plebs’ get to have BDMVs as well.
Thank you @ShinningFinger for the upload, while you were hostile to the original uploader/Private Trackers, you have good intentions at heart.
Thank you for reading, hopefully everyone can have a decent debate/conversation in the future. Just wanted to put my thoughts out as I spent around an hour from reading the comments to writing this.
Lean-Bean
I don’t get it why was the person above mad that you leaked their torrent?
what do they gain from hiding it in the first place, and what do you gain from posting them.
Also, why would someone opt to use private trackers? I am sorry I am new to this, and I don’t understand many things, but I still know that seeding is good so I do it for some time as I don’t have a data plan.
3bood
the hell is happening here
Ashina2001
@3bood One of them is just bitching because they uploaded a torrent here and consider it “illegal”.
HiggerNunter
lmao
shellshock
I just wanna leave my presence here
VASKiRATH
Well this was an entertaining read.
Ingenioussubs
Fuck I can’t believe I read this pepega again. 300th comment let’s go! Which uploader will top 300?
tehpary
Toasting in epic bread
JsKy704
Aw… the comments stopped for a whole week. Was a fun and informative hour-long read.
I’m new to torrenting, literally started 2 months ago, had no idea what torrenting was and how it works (So I will admit, my ratio is probably 200GB to 100MB if I’m lucky)
I’ve started to seed everything I download 2 weeks ago
Just want to thank Nyaa for giving me the experience to learn this for free and this comment section for in-depth knowledge about how PvT and how stuff kinda works despite how messy it was)
@ShinningFinge thanks for the upload btw
Edit: Yes Im a fucking noob, just realize I can transfer my shit into external SSD and force recheck to seed again. Got a 1TB external SSD arriving one month later, hopefully, I can say I’ve helped this community in some way
Still got a few questions regarding seeding, maybe someone could help me with it. Will be coming back to check on this comment section
Ouilie
Just want to leave my presence here too
symonxd
???
yazannj
Just want to leave my presence here too
JimmyThicc
Bruh
PR0XY
my asshole burns
Jollilot
Who wants to extract the English Dub audio for me?
Ouilie
I’m back at it
gangitmo
Let’s get it!!!
Thank you
naiyas
I’m gonna say thank you very much despite all haters comments [appreciated] for great share.
UTTLCT
So I stumbled upon this thread and got curious at the amount of comments. And I just wanted to say that even though pts have a reason to exist, I still don’t think it’s ok to keep stuff exclusive to them, because some of us don’t even have the means to seed stuff. I can’t seed for long because I delete videos after I watch them because I have a small HDD. What I’m getting at is that not everyone has the bandwith/space to survive in a private tracker. For that same reason I’d never download a torrent as big as this, but for releases less bloated, everyone should get at least a chance to download them. They won’t have seeders in a week anyway, so I don’t see a reason to punish a leak that will give us lesser leechers a chance to snatch it if we get lucky. Isn’t the whole purpose of torrenting to share so even the less fortunate get access to stuff? I don’t think it’s reasonable then that the least fortunate are forbidden from accessing stuff due to shitty upload speeds and small HDDs. So it’s either you have to be this rich to own stuff legally, or you have to be this rich to download this torrent. I hope one day to have a better PC with a 10TB HDD to seed everything I download, until that day, it’s the leecher’s life for me.
absinth
@UTTLCT There is a reason why people buy seedboxes, they allow you to have more space that you can utilize in order to survive in PT’s a lot of them also allow you to setup plex soo you can also watch from it. Also BDMVs are not targeted to standard nyaa users that does not care about quality and wants as small as possible with as big seed numbers as possible. BDMV’s are either targeted towards hardcore hoarders who want the purest form they can get or towards encoders who then make your small sized anime.
JsKy704
Oh shit how times have changed from the commend I made 2 months before. In the beginning, I had no idea what private tracker was, and the whole conversation on top taught me a lot about PTs and moral stuff more or less. Got a seedbox and a bigger HDD and life has become so much better.
@UTTLCT, Having no experience in PTs, in the beginning, I had the same thought as what you wrote. Why not just release BDMVs to the general public and let the less fortunate download them, where the harm in that. After reading the whole conversation above 2 months ago, I despised PTs because I had no experience in them and had to take what they said as reference. Though after being in a few, I can not clearly see both sides of the argument. It really boils down to what kind of person you are which will affect the position you take in this matter. Personally, I am a person who enjoys giving back more than I take, which is something PTs crave for, though I am far from the extreme side, still being comparatively new to all this. I could easily go to any renowned PT you can think of and search for a BDMV 6 years ago and most of them still have a respectable number of seeders in them, which is unheard of in Nyaa. Though it has not happened to me yet, but I can see how the feeling of seeing one of your torrent die sucks, or maybe I’m just weird. Though I feel your leecher life as I was also one for quite some time, but luckily reaching a 4.9TB up and 2TB down now without a seedbox, but a big reason for this is due to the purchase of a 5TB HDD. I definitely wish you the best of luck with your new PC and hopefully, you do get to experience the life of being in a PT.
Personally, I dont mind doing the work of uploading BDMVs from PTs to Nyaa, just scared for now on whether Ill get found out and banned. Well only time will tell :)
I wonder what would happen if I leaked some of jdcox251’s One piece BDMVs just for fun ahahhaah
FoolingMode
Aye nice upload. Did I miss something?
Saebre
Sasuga Shingeki no Kyojin!
gub
What a comment section!
Regarding the topic, I think that the fact that this 153,4GB torrent has just 4 seeders pretty much justifies the existence of private trackers.
yazannj2003
Just want to leave my presence here too
iliektetris
Someone said that getting invited to u2 might be possible by asking here, so I’m gonna give it a go: Can anyone invite me to u2?
Kaisersito
Thank you mate :D Amazing, really, thanks to you, I watched the entire series by now in Blu-ray, bless you…
PS: This is the only one that needs seeding :(
surume
still alive???
abirkhan
need seed
iamnotlolicones
henlo
shivansh
Wtf happened here
Mizz141
Got reminded of this shitshow some time ago.
No regrets coming back here.
swaglord
sneed
RidhaFA
Amogus
phantomshadow07
Amogus indeed
ayghub
guys youu should try https://mpv.io/ better then vlc
and yeah fuck AB
DmonHiro
OK, I’m going to be the asshole here and say the following things to the people complaining that PTs are gatekeeping: yes, they are. And to the people who said “Just because we don’t seed, we don’t deserve the HQ stuff?”: no, you don’t. None of us deserve anything. I get that everyone wants HQ stuff, like BDMVs, but no, you don’t deserve it. If you can contribute in some way to a PT, then you get the benefits of one. If you can’t, you don’t. That is how the world works. And let me tel you something else: there would be no need for PT is people just seeded properly. Look at this torrent: it has 2 seeds. Good bloody luck downloading it.
ayghub
@DmonHiro this torrent have more seeds, nyaa shows only the info of the torrent that it being tracking on nyaa’s tracker
Kingughidorah
Thank You for uploading this. As for requests… Junji Ito Collection BDMV or DVDISO, Tokyo Ghoul: Season Two [Blu-ray], Gleipnir: The Complete Season - Blu-ray, Magical Girl Site - Complete Collection (Sub.Blu-Ray)
Alexander-99
Wow, I’ve just finished reading this whole comment feed and want to leave my presence here.
JimmyThicc
Check out my Ultraman stuff
phantomshadow07
What a based comment section
Mizz141
Sometimes I just come back to laugh at this comment section…
mcbaws21
honor among thieves
mcbaws21
honor amogus
Campyfire
haha what the actual fuck did i just read
Impakt
lmao this comment section
Actually, it belongs to Wit Studio and FUNimation.
What customers buy is a license to watch/play/listen the content.
TNCurz
Now this is what I call a fine read
Letrix
Cries with 50KB/s uploads
surume
1 year before and still alive?
AbudiUchiha
I Was Here
cruiserponder
Well. That was one good comment section.
LykaRumi
Indeed it is.
Flops
this comment section epitome of why we cant have nice things
jakecr
Fuck private exclusivities and all the worthless nerds that defend them.
Database973
Still the most commented torrent lol
Sts115
Fuck private trackers, fuck crybabies private trackers uploaders
Crew0X
i love lolis
Gnome
public trackers can’t retain seeders btw :^)
Mitaka
fuck
dumbboy58
:)}
Headlights
Legend
ayylmoa
stojane kakav si na dojenju
yashinarafat29
lol
Arslan2348
Can I get a brief summary plz.
Seems interesting enough.
surume
i ll back
xOmnium
wow
turab
Had fun reading all of it
kidsjamannow
Come back here again to give comment .
AdasiX
Still here.
surume
return here
Kruxy
https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1273100#com-365
Arslan2348
Am I too late?
besiri
Hell yeh!
RiasatSenpai
i was here, bye
LovingCivilian
https://nyaa.iss.one/view/1273100#com-369
warriorwolf
^
“Damn she fine”
;)